2016 Ring Inlays coming unstuck.
GP97 last edited by
I am having the same problem with my ring. My concern is whether a return will be accepted as there is a nasty scratch on the tag that is coming out, this happened several weeks ago and I am certain it's not related. The tag, like other people's in this post, was sticking up when I received the ring and it has only today actually come loose.
Nephiel last edited by
I just received the replacement Eclipse, and was surprised to see it is about twice as thick as the Horizon:
The Horizon was labeled as size 9 but was in fact closer to 9.5 (too large). That, as well as the black inlay coming unstuck, led me to order a replacement.
The replacement Eclipse seems to have the same inner diameter as the Horizon (so it is still too large - will confirm later with a caliper) but the outer diameter is even bigger due to the thickness.
Moreover, the black inlay on the replacement has a bubble, and both inlays have minor blemishes.
Dimensions here: https://github.com/JohnMcLear/nfc-ring-specs
Eclipse should have a deeper groove (ergo thicker band) due to additional materials.
"about twice as thick" is questionable ;)
Nephiel last edited by
You're right about "twice". According to the caliper, the Eclipse is 2.3mm thick, just as the datasheet says. But this Horizon is 1.85mm, and the 'comfort fit' curve makes it seem even thinner.
(By the way, the Eclipse datasheet says Horizon in the first page)
@Nephiel Legend! Thanks for spotting, copy paste ftl ;) Will fix 2mrw (or if you get to it before you could fix it as we now provide libre office files to do so!)
jasok2 last edited by
So there definitely "appears" to be a larger inlay quality production issue going on. This week I got my replacement Horizon and again the inlay is sticking up more than the ring. Its not as bad as the first one and even though I know It will likely be replaced I still have to pay the delivery on that, so I think I will just keep it.
But to make matters worse Today my Eclipse arrived today and it has an annoying blemish that looks like glue under the clear inlay part that ruins the look of the fibre. Its quite difficult to get a good photo of it, but in the flesh its very noticeable to the point where I wouldn't wear it and certainly anyone I tried to show the ring off to would see it and see the poor quality finish. So I will be contacting support about this one.
I did promise @johnyma22 that I would ship back the original Horizon when the replacement arrived so you could take a good look at it and I will but I may wait to see if you or support also want the Eclipse back so I can save on shipping costs and do them both at once.
The first photo is a photo of the replacement Horizon, notice its not nearly as bad as the pictures of the original one I posted above but the inlay is still sticking up. The second one is of the Eclipse. It doesn't look to bad in the photo but its very noticeable when you see it in real life.
Photo 1 - Replacement Horizon
Photo 2 - Eclipse
@jasok2 is having very bad luck :P It's also worth noting that specific models (horizon 7, 12.5, eclipse 7, eclipse 5) had much higher QA fail rates (due to raised inlays) than others. The factory think it's due to moisture entering the ring. I think it's caused by heat and lack of keying, we're investigating after CNY so it's fixed in the next revision.
Happy to change both at once. RE blemish, some dust got in or it looks scuffed? QC'ing the fibre is tough because you gotta look from every angle and rotate the ring, takes a long time!
Obviously with first revisions of any new product it's not going to be as good as the 100+ revisions of the 2013 model. That's just the nature of new product development, the main thing is we do everything we can to ensure NFC Ring wearers do get what they want, even if it takes a few attempts! You can see evidence as our commitment to this with the CF/Stealth bomber vouchers campaign that we ran..
vaticanuk last edited by
Hmm... My Horizon 8 has started doing this over the past week(ish). Ignored it at first because it wasn't too bad, but its getting worse to the point where the inlays catch on things now :(
I'll mail support with photos :(
jasok2 last edited by
@jasok2 is having very bad luck :P
Thankfully my luck has improved by 50%
Support gave me a voucher to replace one of the two rings and cover postage. It was a bit frustrating and also a bit funny because they gave me the full amount minus 1 pence. Unfortunately my credit card has a minimum of something weird like 37 pence per transaction so I was a bit stuck until I figured out that i can get around the issues with paypal.
anyway finally I have a very nice Eclipse ring. The Horizon still has slightly raised inlays but I suspect i will get some time out of it before the inlay breaks.
@johnyma22 I am posting two faulty rings back to you today. I'm putting 2 rings in the one box to save shipping costs.
HoTWiReZ last edited by
I'm having a similar issue, though mine and my wife's rings have this happening on the opposite direction to what I've seen in here thus far (in the direction of the rings' circumferences). Hers arrived with an edge to it there that grabs things, and mine developed an edge to it that now if I touch it it is obvious that the inlay will peel directly off the ring. I've stopped wearing it because of this and I'm rethinking purchasing the front door lock we were planning to get.
I was thinking about this and something I think I saw John say at one point was about 'keying', and keying the edge of the ring so that when the inlay is poured in it can fill a keyed slot around the perimeter would be the only way I could see these things staying put permanently. Maybe that kind of thing is too difficult to do with ceramic, though. I'm not a mechanical engineer.
Sorry I delayed my response so long; I'm unaccustomed to responding in these places and needed to get something set up to host the picture of my ring that shows what I'm talking about (though it's not as sharp as I wanted since it's using my phone).
My ring with inlay separating
We're doing keying, on our next blanks we're going to do a slightly deeper groove at the edge points, this additional depth should in theory create a "wedge" forcing the epoxy to stay in the groove.. It's annoying because it only affects some sizes :P
Sadly I have the same issue. I didn't want to send my rings in because I love them but it gets worse so now I have to :-(
Yea it sucks but the main thing is we have a process (thanks to you guys) to deal with stuff like this. Pesky bleeding edge is pesky :P
FiletMignon last edited by
I had a similar issue with my Horizon where the black inlay actually completely fell out. I superglued it back in, but now it cannot be read, at least not by my phone or keyduino. Is there any good way to fix this? I was thinking I could replace the inlay myself, if it is possible to just get the inlays.