MadDave123 last edited by
Has anyone tested the rings (standard & alpha) with the Nexus 4? Either the test rings or the production ones.
There seems to have been a lot of confusion about whether the Aphpa ring was actually needed for the Nexus 4, since John accidentally mentioned the N4 instead of the N5 in one of the updates. Some people (myself included) had previously contacted support asking to change to an Alpha ring based on teh info in that update, but now it'd be good to know if it's safe to switch back to the standard ring.
I think until a user who actually owns a N4 get their ring, we'll never know. :roll:
@confidence did you use your sweet spot stickers?
i got my ring yesterday and set it up tonight.
i got the regular ring for use with the n4. [b:q9wjnf6r]I think you need an alpha ring for the nexus4!!![/b:q9wjnf6r]
With my ring reading is inconstant at best. I'm currently locked out of my phone as i didn' think to set a backup password and i can't get my ring to scan again. It worked the first time but not the second...
I haven't placed the stickers on the phone as i use a case and am testing it without the case on for now. I'll be placing the stickers once i can get it to read the ring consistently.
After multiple power cycles of the phone i finally got it to read the ring again. I think it may be a problem with my phone. It seems to only ready once per power cycle :cry:
From a security point i did find a small hole:
After power cycling android reverts back to the standard unlock for me. i was able to get into the settings > apps > nfc unlock section and almost disable the unlock app before the screen was locked by the app again. If i had practiced it a few more times i think i could have disabled the app before it relocked the phone.
RE Reading once, that's realllllly weird.. Sounds nasty! Either way I will send you through an alpha ring just to check to see the difference in read performance..
Yea RE Security we know about that bug, it's getting a fix on the 14th and should be available to beta users on the 16th or so :)
Confidence, see if you can restart your device in safe mode so that you can either switch off NFC unlocking or add a secondary method.
Then you have a bit of breathing room while you see if you can get a better lock on the sweet spot.
I used the included inlay and the read/write app several time to confirm the locations that work best. I also placed the stickers.
The phone works brilliantly with the loose inlay. Its rather poor with the ring itself. I've powered cycled several times now and can't get the ring to pick up on either tag. Its pretty strange.
I got it to read the actual ring maybe 4 times total and now nothing...
Sounds very strange @confidence, pretty sure if the lose inlay isn't working something is really broken with NFC on your device :(
I've seen a few posts regarding faulty NFC in these phones, with intermittent function.
I use an NFC tag on my keyring to unlock my phone...works every time.
When John posted about how flaky the normal ring was with the N4, I upgraded to the Alpha ring...hopefully someone get an Alpha soon to test things out.
I've seen a few posts regarding faulty NFC in these phones, with intermittent function. Just to verify, is it now not working with either the ring or the loose inlay tag?
I'm also wondering if there is other software that is 'feature-adding' to the NFC function on the phone - I've seen reports that Samsung's Beam function can mess with normal operation for tag reading. Is there anything like that on your phone that might be activating after the phone has been running for a short while?
Sorry, should have been clearer - I was referring to Confidence's intermittent issues. It's odd that it's working sometimes on initial power on and then stopping after that first time.
I took the ring and tag to work with me today. I have a few coworkers who really want one of these and will be happy to help test it.
So far two people have tested it with their Galaxy S4s. We found out there was not hotspot data for the S4. We've fixed that little problem :mrgreen:
Looks like each phone is unique in how it reads. One S4 does well with the ring, the other doesn't but douse have a bit longer read range for the loose tag than the other one.
We did find that holding the ring to the Nexus for a few seconds on the sweet spot gets it to read more consistently. However, even then, it's not very reliable. Given what I've learned with the two S4s it could just be an issue with my phone.
I still suspect an alfa ring would do a lot better on the Nexus.
If you are interested, I'll try the ring with some more phones at lunch and see how they do compared to the Nexus and let you know. Like i said, there are quite a few people here who have been waiting to see how this works. I should have plenty of willing testers.
Confidence, it will certainly be interesting to see if the Alpha ring changes the read performance. That's pretty cool with the test data, the dodgy S4 possibly has poor antenna connections on the battery or an aftermarket battery with a bad antenna.
I've tried a host of different phones and tables with the ring now. none of them do very well.
With my phone its still rather hard to read. I find that the ring has to be perfectly flat against the phone to read. I also have to leave it there a while before it picks up. It seems to help if i slowly move it left or right on the sweetspot if it hasn't picked up after about 3 seconds. If the ring is tilted in any way it doesn't read at all.
Ironically the larger tag is the hardest for any of the phones i've tried to read. The smaller tag picks up easier, which is not something i expected.
It seems that when i power cycle the phone it picks up the ring easier when it's presented right after the power cycle. Maybe this is just some kind of placebo or psychosomatic/magical thinking. It just seems like the ring can be held a bit farther away and at an angle for that first read right after the power cycle. Maybe there is some kind of power saving feature that android kicks in a few seconds after reboot that turns down the power to the nfc antenna. Maybe this power saving feature it's not in effect for a few seconds after reboot. Maybe, i'm just crazy...
I really need to order an alpha ring to see if that will read better. After trying this ring with all the devices i have i will bet that an alpha ring will be the best choice for most people.
confidence, what are the inlay covers of your ring?
standard black for the small one and silver for the large one.
lilrayman last edited by
I've seen a few posts regarding faulty NFC in these phones, with intermittent function.[/quote:2cvvji73]
Im in the exact same boat, however I also have a Nexus 7 (2013) which I may try and use it with, I just hope I receive an Alpha ring, as my email confirmation still had a normal on it :?
Hi mate, if the confirmation says anything other than what you're expecting then you might need to query it, because what it says you're getting is what you'll receive.
That said, if you were an automatic change to Alpha and have been automatically re-changed back to Normal then roll with it and see how you go. If you have issues then here's the place to report them after that, and we'll help you through any troubles you're having.
Most readability issues have been sorted out though, the ones that confidence was having may be device based, not product based if you get that.
Keep us informed either way.
Im in the exact same boat, however I also have a Nexus 7 (2013) which I may try and use it with,[b:fsr39xot] I just hope I receive an Alpha ring, as my email confirmation still had a normal on it[/b:fsr39xot][/quote:fsr39xot]
I got the same email...I replied back saying that my Normal ring was upgraded to an Alpha on 12/22 because of N4 problems. Got an email back instantly that my email was received, but we'll have to wait & see what shipping email says.